Custom Orders

Custom Baked Goods in Pittsburgh

Custom cakes, cookie boxes and party platters for Pittsburgh weddings, showers, corporate events and holidays — every item on our menu can be customized.

Free quote within 24 hours · No payment now · Pickup in Aspinwall · Just want the regular menu?

1. Tell us about your event
Occasion *
How many people? *
At least 5 days out. Larger events need 1–2 weeks.
Pickup only, 9am–5:30pm, at 313 Freeport Rd, Aspinwall. We'll confirm the exact time when we reply.
2. Request a custom item (optional)

Want something that isn't on our menu? Describe it — flavors, style, theme, colors — and add a reference photo if you have one.

0 / 700 characters
JPG or PNG, up to 5 MB.
3. Add from our menu (optional)

Want to add any of our existing menu items to your order? Set the quantities here — prices shown are per item.

Signature Bakes

  • Cinnamon Coffee CakeFull Size | 9x13"$35.00
  • Classic Cinnamon Rolls w/ Vanilla Icing6 medium size rolls$22.00
  • Caramelized Brown Butter Banana Bread1 full loaf or 8 mini loaves$26.00
  • Fudgy Brownies9 pieces$30.00
  • Chocolate Chip Cookies6 cookies$18.00
  • Tamreye Date Pie1 pie$32.00
  • Pistachio Rose Loaf CakeFull loaf$47.00

Savory

  • Organic Kalamata Olive Bread Twists6 twists$18.00
  • Whole Wheat Protein & Fiber Bagels — Plain6 bagels$16.00
  • Whole Wheat Protein & Fiber Bagels — Everything6 bagels$17.00
  • Whole Wheat Protein & Fiber Bagels — Pumpkin & Sesame Seeds6 bagels$20.00

Gluten-Free

  • Gluten-Free Carrot Cake Muffins12 muffins (low sugar)$36.00

Protein Snacks

  • Tri Cookie Box (6 of each)$36.00
  • Mocha Chip Cookies6 cookies$18.00
  • Cinnamon Roll Cookies6 cookies$18.00
  • PB Almond Crunch Cookies6 cookies$18.00
4. Your details
5. Anything else? (optional)
0 / 700 characters
Not sure what to ask for? See what else we make
  • Party platters — mix and match from our menu for any celebration.
  • Cookie boxes — choose your flavours in boxes of 6, 12, 18 or 24.
  • Corporate orders — bulk pricing for offices, meetings and events.
  • Protein snack packs — pick your flavours and quantities for meal prep.
  • Holiday specials — seasonal treats and holiday gift boxes.
  • Wholesale & cafes — wholesale pricing and regular delivery.

Custom Orders FAQ

Common questions about ordering custom cakes, cookie platters & event catering from Lay's Kitchen in Pittsburgh

How far in advance should I place a custom order?

Custom orders need at least 5 days' notice, and 1–2 weeks for larger events like weddings and corporate gatherings. Fill out the custom request form with your event date and headcount and we'll confirm what's possible.

Where do I pick up my custom order?

Custom orders are pickup only, at our Aspinwall kitchen (313 Freeport Rd, Aspinwall PA 15215), between 9am and 5:30pm. Pick your preferred time on the request form and we'll confirm it when we reply. (For same-day delivery of our regular menu items, order through DoorDash.)

What kinds of events do you bake for?

Weddings, baby and bridal showers, birthdays, corporate meetings, holiday parties, Eid al-Fitr and Eid al-Adha gatherings, Ramadan iftars, Mother's Day, Christmas, Easter, and more. We bake party platters, cookie boxes, protein snack packs and holiday gift boxes in our licensed Aspinwall home kitchen, and take wholesale orders for cafes. Anything you'd serve baked goods at — we can do it.

Do you offer wholesale or recurring corporate orders?

Yes — we work with local cafes and offices on recurring wholesale orders. Choose 'Wholesale / Café' on the request form, or email us at layskitchenhq@gmail.com with your weekly or monthly needs.

Can I customize a flavor that isn't on the menu?

Often, yes. We can adjust fillings, frostings, decorations, and flavor combinations for most of our baked goods. Describe what you'd like in the 'Request a custom item' section of the request form.

How do I pay for a custom order?

Custom orders are paid by Venmo or Zelle once confirmed — there's no payment when you submit the request. For larger orders we'll send a written confirmation with total cost before the order is locked in.